I don't even know how to begin. That's how awesome this year's list is.
I think that we can agree that it's been a tough year - the Recession! H1N1! War! - and the general atmosphere seems to be one of muted tension. No one has any money, we're all kind of scared and sad and everyone seems to need a
handknit afghan from their grandma and a bowl of homemade soup and maybe a showing of It's A Wonderful Life.
But in
Oprahland, everything is hunky dory. Expensively, self-
affirmingly hunky dory.
First up:
What is it?A big gaudy sparkly Christmas ball.Who is it for?"
For newlyweds decorating their first tree."
What's wrong with it?It is TWENTY SIX DOLLARS for ONE SPARKLY CHRISTMAS BALL. And Oprah wants me to "buy several"! The heck I will, Oprah. I don't even like my OWN tree enough to spend over one hundred dollars on FOUR GAUDY BALLS, thank you.
Grade: D.
What is it?Appealing simplistic vintage racing car Who is it for?
Not actual children, I suspect, since they're $60. Each. But it's a website for children, and so I guess they are intended for children. "
Exclusive" children.
What's wrong with it?It's a toy car that costs $60. Really? You can't see what's wrong with that? Do you need me to explain it to you?
Grade: C-. It's cute. If it was something that real people could afford, and not just "exclusive", special people, I would grade it higher.
What is it?Silver Reebox EasyTone Reeinspire Sneakers with magical leg and "tush" firming properties.
Who is it for?The saggy tushed of your acquaintance.
What's wrong with it?Suggesting
someone's "tush" needs firming on Christmas morning seems risky to me. As does giving someone shoes that cost $125 and that are METALLIC SILVER. There are situations in which I might wear metallic silver running shoes, but most of them involve running from a bear on Mars.
Grade: F. Seriously, do not give someone devices intended for toning their butt on Christmas. Just don't do that.
What is it?Semi-precious stone and leather bracelets.
Who is it for?"
Artsy" people. "
Give one in a friend's favorite colour", chirps the magazine! And at $170, that had better be one HECK of a friend.
What's wrong with it?Really? People give their friends' $170 bracelets? And I dunno, maybe you think that bracelet is $170 worth of awesome, but I don't.
Grade: D. I dunno, it's a bracelet. An expensive beady bracelet. Whoop-
dee-
doo.
What is it?
It is the
iPod nano. I'm not even going to link to it, because you KNOW what it is.
Who is it for?zzzzz. It's an
iPod nano. You either have one or you want one or you very self-righteously do not WANT one because you're not part of the herd
blahblahblah. In short, it's what I would like for Christmas but will not get because WE ARE IN A FREAKING RECESSION.
What's wrong with it?IT IS EXPENSIVE.
Grade: Are you Santa? Are you reading this list hoping that I'll drop a hint about what I want?
What is it?It is a black quilted biker jacket that will look flattering on very few women.
Who is it for?I do not know. Who wears these things? The magazine says that it's "high style", which might explain my mystification.
What's wrong with it?I play this little game with the Oprah Christmas list - I cover up the description so I can just look, aghast, at the suggested present, and then I dramatically reveal the price to myself. $329! This coat costs $329!
Eeek!
Grade: D-.
What is it?HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.
It is a hot pink trapper hat from Kate Spade.
HAHAHAHAHA.
Who is it for?
A complete tool. Seriously, look at the picture of that thing.
What's wrong with it?
Where to begin? It's hot pink fake fur? It costs $195? It's foolish looking?
Grade: I do not know. If there is someone who you know and dislike and suspect would wear that stupid thing, and if you have a LOT of money, you could buy them that hat and then snicker whenever they wore it. But that would make you not a very nice person. Perhaps you should buy yourself the bad hat, nasty person. D-.
What is it?Pretty cookies that look like Christmas lights.Who is it for?
People who like cookies. Or people who have always wanted to eat a Christmas light.
What's wrong with it?EIGHT COOKIES = $20. We're in the worst financial crisis since the Depression and some people are buying cutesy cookies that are apparently worth their weight in gold. Cookies - in case you were wondering - are not actually worth a lot of money. They're CUTE, though and maybe you're rich. By all means.
Grade: C-.
What is it?It's a purple aluminum tube filled with makeup brushes.
Who is it for?Ladies who like makeup.
What's wrong with it?Let's see: it's reasonably-enough priced at $20, and it's cute and I can actually imagine people being happy to get it. So not much.
Grade: B+
What is it?
It is a merino wool scarf with sharks printed on it.
Who is it for?I can't even begin to imagine. Seriously, my imagination has failed me.
What's wrong with it?A) It's ugly.
B) It costs $225. Does my being appalled by ugly $225 scarves with sharks crudely printed on them indicate that something is desperately wrong with me? I really hope not.
Grade: D-.
What is it?It is a long sleeved t-shirt with a Christmas tree on it.Who is it for?People who get that the shirt is "witty" and "fashionable."
What's wrong with it?
It's exactly the same thing as the sweater with the Christmas tree on it that your grandma likes to wear on Christmas day. I love grandmotherly fashion, so I think it's an awesome t-shirt AND I'm also amused by the idea of fashionable types wearing a grandma t-shirt.
Hee.
Grade: B.
What is it?12 Pairs of 12 Days of Christmas Baby socks.Who is it for?A baby.
What's wrong with it?Well, they're cute. But they're also $45. They're fun, though, and nicely packaged and perhaps you're an affluent grandparent who has gone half-crazed with the joys of first-time
grandparenthood.
Grade: B-
What is it?Tea cups, saucers and spoons. Grandmotherly? Oh, heck no! "Their tutti-
frutti interiors prove they're wild at heart."
Who is it for?I think they're kind of cute.
What's wrong with it?Nothing. They're $28 and they're pretty. The Oprah text made me snicker, though - even TEA CUPS need to be "extreme" now? Really? We're all so hysterically terrified of being grandmotherly that even our tea cups radiate youthful vitality? Does this seem necessary?
Grade: A.
What is it?
A copy of If You Give A Pig A Party or If You Take A Mouse To The Movies with a matching stuffed animal.Who is it for?Children and/or the immature.
What's wrong with it?
Well, I have a strict No Stuffed Animals For Gifts policy that I try and live by. But they ARE pretty cute. And they're only $10 and the proceeds go towards children's charities. So now I am having an inner battle over the whole No Stuffed Animals things vs. Cute and affordable
Grade: I think this is pretty nice - affordable and cute.
What is it?
"Stunning" Promise Me Chocolate Truffle Gems with edible gold on them.Who is it for?Did you know that my husband gives me nice chocolates every year for Christmas?
What's wrong with it?
They're pretty! They're $26! If my husband saw them, he would give them to me for Christmas.
Grade: B+. I don't need to eat a box of chocolates, thank you. But oh, how I love them.
What is it?Reversible bubble parkas. That cost $15.... wait, $10.
Who is it for?The chilled. Those who like coat options. A friend of mine who hasn't had a winter coat IN NORTHERN ONTARIO in EIGHT years because she has growing kids who always eat up the coat budget.
What's wrong with it?
Well, should we talk about the ethics of buying at
Walmart? But on the other hand, for $10, you probably know a lot of people who could use a nice warm coat. Like my poor chilly friend.
Grade: B+.
What is it?A MHS-PM1 Webbie HD photo and video camera with a rotating head for taking self-portraits.
Who is this for?
Teenage girls. The vain.
What's wrong with it?It's $170. But I can imagine a lot of teenage girls being very happy to open it. Now teach them to take APPROPRIATE self-portraits, please.
Grade: A slightly worried B.
What is it?Rubbery incense drawer inserts. What? I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHAT THESE ARE! (there's no online link.)
Who is this for?The highly fragrant.
What's wrong with it?IT IS ONE HUNDRED AND FIVE DOLLARS FOR FIVE DRAWER LINERS. I AM NOT KIDDING. ONE HUNDRED AND FIVE DOLLARS. FOR FIVE DRAWER LINERS.
Grade: I'm too dazzled to think in grades.
What is it?Wool-cashmere gloves with electromagnetic fabric fingertips for typing on your iPod.
Who is this for?
Someone who can't stop
texting even though they're outside IN THE COLD.
What's wrong with it?
Oh, where to begin. But they're also only $30. So I don't know. Do you know an addicted
texter in danger of losing their fingers to frostbite? Then TA DA.
Grade: C-.
What is it?Ballet flats that roll up to a very small size.
Who is this for?
People who wear perilously high heels and who could at ANY MINUTE need a pair of sensible back-up shoes.
What's wrong with it?They're $22 and for the right person, hey, they might be kind of handy, eh? I have FREQUENTLY realized that the distance I had to walk was COMPLETELY incompatible with my adorable footwear.
Grade: B+
What is it?The Reclaim Phone.
Who is it for?
People who want to still feel "eco-friendly" and yet have new stuff.
What's wrong with it?
Oh, NOTHING. We're on a depressing good streak of gift suggestions here.
Grade: A.
What is it?Five pairs of reading glasses, one pair of sun readers and a hard case.
Who is it for?People with strained, elderly eyes. Right, Dad?
What's wrong with it?People don't like it implied that they need reading glasses, at least the touchy people of MY ACQUAINTANCE. But at $35 it's a good deal and maybe your relatives are less touchy than mine. (They're just touchy because they're old.)
Grade: Depends on your gift give-
ees.
What is it?An anti-tarnish box for silver jewelry.
Who is it for?I'm sure you can figure it out.
What's wrong with it?
It's a bit dull. But it's $16.
Grade: B.
What is it?
Layered gourmet cookie mixes in jars. You know, the kind women's magazines are always suggesting you make to save you money on Christmas presents?
Who is it for?"
Hostess gifts" the magazine suggests. I think that it would suggest "Here I am! Make me cookies!". Of course, if I'm coming to your house, freshly-baked cookies WOULD be nice.
What's wrong with it?YOU CAN MAKE THIS YOURSELF. VERY, VERY EASILY. But if you can't and you've always wanted to give a cookie mix in a jar, here is your big chance.
Grade: B.
Oh, thank goodness I'm done the "Good deal!" gift suggestions. That was killing me.
What is it?It is a
key locket and A FREAKING STEAL at $325.
Who is it for?The wealthy AND sentimental.
What's wrong with it?As an object, it is pretty enough. Of course, it's $325, and if you want to spend $325 on me, it had better not be on jewelry. But since everyone I know is a normal person and thus adversely affected by THE RECESSION, I have NO ONE in my life who COULD buy me a $325 locket. Poor me.
Grade: D.
What is it?Fragonard Perfume Who is it for?Perfume is a very nice present - if you're a bit cash-y - but I would be VERY careful about surprising someone with a bottle of perfume that they've never smelled before. Perfume is a very individual thing and it's probably best to give this to
someone who has asked for it.
What's wrong with it?Probably nothing. It's probably a very nice perfume.
Grade: That depends. But don't go just randomly buying people perfume.
What is it?Good grief.
It is TEN notecards and envelopes for $45. Are you MADE OUT OF MONEY?
Who is it for?It is for the very well-off to give each other as an amusing little very rich gift.
What's wrong with it?If you are the Queen or very wealthy, then nothing. But what BOTHERS me about lists like this is that they subtly imply that only extravagant gifts are good enough - and that's not a message that most people NEED to hear these days, is it?
Grade: C.
What is it?An extra-glamorous boa.
Who is it for?Your aunt, the nun.
What's wrong with it?I think it is VERY ugly. But maybe you think it's playful and fun. At $38, it's not unimaginably
pricey, at least.
Grade: B-.
What is it?
A "
handcrafted tote covered in leather roses (that) looks like a bouquet on your arm." It is also $585.
Who is it for?I am buying this for a certain friend if I win one of those big payout lotteries. Otherwise: rich people.
What's wrong with it?IT COSTS FIVE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY FIVE DOLLARS.
Sheesh!
Grade: Once I win that lottery, my friend is gonna be a happy girl.
What is it?Blood-orange - the goriest of the fruits! - scented soap, lip balm and hand cream.
Who is this for?It's PRETTY enough and I can imagine a lot of women liking it.
What's wrong with it?
"Make It A Threesome" said the chipper heading on it. I am not kidding. And then I threw up. I might be kidding about that, but still. Tasteless, Oprah.
Grade: B+ for the actual thing itself and a scowl for a GIFT GUIDE in a women's magazine that I now will not let my ten year old child read.
What is it?Monogrammed and hideous playing cards.Who is this for?People who want to play cards AND BE HYPNOTIZED BY THEIR HYPNOTIC PATTERNS at the same time.
What's wrong with it?They're ugly AND they cost $55. Fifty five dollars! For two decks of cards! Good grief!
Grade: F.
What is it?Tagua nut polished bead necklaces Who is this for?
Not me. I hate big clunky necklaces.
What's wrong with it?It's $55. Other than that, make sure that your recipient is a fan of the big clunky necklace.
Grade:
Uhh, a B minus?
What is it?Watches printed with pieces of very famous paintings.
Who is this for?Someone who wants to look at The Kiss
everytime they check the time.
What's wrong with it?I have strong negative feelings about novelty watches, but they're not universally held, apparently.
Grade: C.
What is it?Cuff bracelets made from semi-precious stones and BUFFALO BONE. BUFFALO BONE? REALLY?
Who is this for?People who like wearing animal bones on their wrists. Scary, scary people.
What's wrong with it?Um. Is there something uniquely fashionable about buffalo bones that I don't know about? What makes a buffalo's bones more worth $49 than, let's say, Elsie The Milk Cow's bones?
Grade: A rather-grossed out D.
What is it?A lightweight and brightly coloured high definition TV.
Who is this for?/What's Wrong With It?
I could be snarky about the kind of people who get and give tvs for presents, but in all honestly, when our tv died, my mother-in-law gave us a new one for Christmas. And that? WAS AWESOME. Maybe this year we'll get this one!
Grade: Gimme!
What is it?A hamper of "the world's best foods." Who is it for?I think I see some soft cheeses in there, so not anyone pregnant.
What's wrong with it?Oh, I like food. Hampers of classy foodstuffs? That's awesome.
Grade: A.
What is it?Clinique's High Shade To Go Collection Who is it for?Makeup wearing lady types.
What's wrong with it?I've written this before and I'll doubtlessly live to write it again - the problem with big sets of lip gloss or lipsticks or eye shadows or WHATEVER is that there are four useable colours and then a bunch of crap in stupid colours that no one will ever, ever wear. The colours in this set look fairly okay, but it's still risky.
Grade: B-
What is it?"Sorbet hued" satin pajamas. (edited to add: Whoops! they're not satin, they're sateen.)
Who is it for?
Not ME. I hate satin pajamas - it combines the best of being chilled and being slippery enough to fall out of bed ALL NIGHT! But maybe you live someplace warm and sleep on a lower bed than I do. You may have them. They're pretty, at least.
What's wrong with it?
This may actually be more of a "What's wrong with ME?" sort of thing. Why am I so easily chilled? Why do I fall out of bed so much? Why is this freaking list so long?
Grade: A nice present for someone who is not me and who probably lives someplace warm. An A for them.
What is it?Candy Basket Gel Squares Who is it for?People who like candy.
What's wrong with it?A nice candy, affordable - $6 for 15! - so not much. What, you thought I hated EVERYTHING?
Grade: A.
What is it?
Oh my gosh.
A pretty enough necklace made of cheery coloured baubles and A GIANT PURPLE RIBBON.
Who is it for?/What's wrong with it?If the necklace DIDN'T have the big purple ribbon, I can imagine a LOT of women liking it. As it is, though, I would only give it to the extremely whimsical.
Grade: C.
What is it?Little dressy clutches.
Who is it for?Women who need a dressy clutch.
What's wrong with it?According to the magazine, these are a BARGAIN. They look expensive, but they only cost $113!
IMPORTANT NEWS FLASH: ONE HUNDRED AND THIRTEEN DOLLARS IS STILL A LOT OF MONEY.Grade: D for duh.
What is it?Ornate resin cuffs crowned with huge gaudy crystal thingys.
Who is it for?
People who like giant jewelry.
What's wrong with it?Unless someone specifically asks for this, I would be cautious of giving it - it's $96 and that's rather a lot of money to spend on "distinctive" jewelry.
Grade: B.
What is it?Chanel No. 5 Bath Oil Who Is It For?
I really wish I hadn't started this catergory. Who do you THINK wants perfumed bath oil?
What's wrong with it?
Well, it's $75. And we're in the middle of a recession. Now, maybe this is what you want for Christmas more than anything in the whole world, but most people I know would be happier with a bottle of perfume than a bottle of bath oil - more bang for your buck. And while it's still a very nice thing, I must point out that a bottle of Mr. Bubble is quite nice, too, and doesn't cost nearly a hundred dollars.
Grade: C.
What is it?
It is a plush giraffe coat for a baby.
What's wrong with it?
(see how I just skipped over the whole Who Is This For? thing. Yeah. Tired of that now.) It's a $45 coat that looks like a giraffe. It's cute enough, I guess, and there's nothing really wrong with it.
Grade: B, I guess.
What Is It?
It is nut pie or cake or something like that.
Who is it for?
Nut pie lovers.
What's wrong with it?
Nut allergies are SO common these days that I would be seriously leery of sending someone a nut-based baked good. And also? Nuts are yucky. Bleh. There's nothing that ruins a nice piece of baking like a bunch of gritty nuts thrown in there like gravel.
Grade: C
What is it?
It is an "Art Deco minaudiere". What the heck is THAT?
Who is it for?
I can at least make out that it's for girly make-up loving women.
What's wrong with it?
Well, it has a pretensious name. I mean, REALLY. It's a compact that holds body powder and eye shadow. Does slapping a French name on it really make it worth $98?
Grade: How do I say D in French?
And that's it!
This year's list was a doozy. My FAVORITE thing was the buffalo bone bracelet - I feel sort of gaggy just thinking about it! Awesome!